You know... I actually used this line on my super crazy religious aunt... and she totally blew my mind by coming back with the response that she actually believed all those gods existed, but that they were all either dead or powerless, and that Yahweh was the only "living God". Yes, she seriously said she believed Zeus and Thor and Quetzalcoatl were real.

It was at that point I realize she was completely bonkers and bowed out of the conversation.