Just because both are under construction doesn't mean we can't possibly have any idea whatsoever as to which one is better, or doing things right

Well, it does. You can guess, or place bets as to which one will be better, but until they both proclaim they have finished development, we do not know.

With regard to who is doing it right - this is a good point, but it depends on the demographic they are trying to attract. Personally, if done correctly, War Z could be much more successful in terms of numbers, as it offers a much more casual style of play.

From a DayZ point of view, this is the opposite, and appears very bad. DayZ strives for authenticity and delivers it in spectacular fashion.

It's not a bad thing that War Z caters more for carebears, casual gamers and COD kiddies than DayZ, it is just filling another niche within the zombie survival genre in general, so find it hard to hold a grudge.

I will certainly play DayZ and think the experience it will deliver will be phenomenal - probably one of the best there is to experience.

But sometimes it's nice to relax, have a few beers and have a laugh instead, which is where WarZ comes in.